Daniel R. Patterson Daniel R. Patterson

Advent Through Luther’s Eyes 2: Nativity

In chapter 3 of Martin Luther’s Christmas Book, Luther uses the nativity to situate Christ in relation to the world’s powers. His basic premise is that the timing of Christ’s birth was neither irrelevant, nor happenstance. The nativity can only be rightly conceived within the political and social milieu of the time.

Luther notes that Christ’s birth coincided with Emperor Augustus’ decree that all people in the empire should return to their hometown to register for tax purposes. So Jesus was not born in peacetime, however peaceful it was, but into a nation under the yoke of the Roman Empire.

But unlike the relationship of my birth to the affairs of the state at the time of my birth back in 1979, the birth of Christ, Luther argues, is in direct relationship with the political powers of the time. He claims that, “At the very first moment of his life, Christ and his parents had to give evidence of his obedience, not to God, but to the heathen emperor, the enemy of the Jews.” At this point in the story, the cosmic significance of the baby does not shine through, especially since Christ is born during an act of servitude to the emperor by his parents. The birth of Jesus, one might say, occurs while bowing the knee.

The nativity is also situated within a particular social dynamic, which can be seen in the events that occur on Joseph and Mary’s arrival at Bethlehem. Luther reflects: “How unobtrusively and simply do those events take place on earth that are so heralded in heaven!” While the women who carried Rome’s future rulers were pampered in the lap of luxury, “the mother of God, on foot in midwinter trudged her weight across the fields. How unequal it all was!” Luther was appalled at the inhumanity of those who would not create space for a pregnant woman when she arrived at Bethlehem. It was this inhumanity that lead them to a cow shed “to there bring forth the Maker of all creatures.”

Luther observes that the inhumanity of those who filled the inns bespeaks the darkness that had befallen Bethlehem. “Shame on you, wretched Bethlehem!” is a cry of one who is indignant. The darkness is for us to be clearly seen. The “cutthroats lounged like lords in the inn,” and so “did not recognize what God was doing in the stable.” The carousers were full of booze and grub, yet “God left them empty, and this comfort and treasure was hidden from them. Oh, what a dark night it was in Bethlehem that this light should not have been seen.” It was a long and dark walk from Nazareth, and it was a long and dark night in the cowshed.

In the nativity, Luther observes two worlds that have no regard for God’s world. The emperor’s rule hovered like a ghost over Christ’s birth. The mob ruled over Christ’s birth with indifference. Luther takes his reader by the hand to show how Joseph, Mary, and “the Maker of all creatures” ended up firstly in Bethlehem, and then out the back in a cowshed. Much like the unknowing collusion of the mob and the state at Christ’s death, we see here, the unknowing collusion of the state and the mob at Christ’s birth: “Thus shows God that he has no regard for what the world is and has and does. And the world shows that it does not know or consider what God is and has and does."

The emperor and the mob did not realise they were ushering the baby to “the first throne of this king” —the manger. It was not the final seat from which he would rule.

Luther cannot hide his nervous twitch. What is so terrifying about this king on his throne? Don’t be mistaken, Luther is not finding cause to love God because God is a baby in a manger—who doesn’t gush over a baby? On the contrary, Luther’s grasping for this king is grounded in the orthodox claim that lies at the heart of the nativity: “That is why Christ took on our humanity, save for sin, that he should not terrify us but rather that with love and favour he should console and confirm.” Here lies the “Maker of all creatures” as one of us, who came to us, for us.

 

 

 

 

 

Read More
Daniel R. Patterson Daniel R. Patterson

Advent Through Luther’s Eyes 1: Annunciation

Introduction

It seems fitting that my Advent reading this year concludes with Martin Luther’s sermons and reflections on the Nativity. The collection that I’m reading is edited by the long serving English born Yale Reformation historian Rolland H. Bainton. The little book was first published in 1948 and is called Martin Luther’s Christmas Book.

The task of this and the following six posts is not to dissect Luther’s theology bit by bit to show him up as one still draped in the vestiges of Rome or as one not reformed. Rather, I want to read him with the Christmas spirit that supposedly characterises human interaction at this time of year. While I have deep reservations and scepticism about such a spirit, there is no substitute for generously reading our theological forebears.

The little book is comprised of an introduction by Bainton followed by eight pieces by Luther. These include:

  1. Annunciation
  2. Visitation
  3. Nativity
  4. Shepherds
  5. Herod
  6. Wise Men
  7. Presentation
  8. From Heaven High

Over the next seven days before Christmas I’ll write a short piece on each text (but not the second because it replicates the theme of the first) with the last one falling on Christmas Day.

Annunciation

In Chapter 1, Luther takes up the annunciation of the Son of God. Luther begins by framing the coming of the Son of God against two backdrops. The first is the genealogy of sinners at the beginning of the Gospel of Matthew. Luther pens the words: “God holds before us this mirror of sinners that we may know that he is sent to sinners, and from sinners is willing to be born.” This is the spiritual context into which the son to be born is to be announced. The second backdrop for the annunciation of the Son of God is the political and economic poverty of the time.

Luther summarises the context of the announcement of the coming of the Son of God when he writes: “To this poor maiden marvellous things were announced: that she should be the mother of the All Highest, whose name should be the Son of God. He would be a King and of his Kingdom there would be no end.” And with this Luther has framed his principle point of interest.

Luther’s desire to contextualise the annunciation is not to draw attention to the miraculous nature of the God-human child. Nor is he caught up with the baby’s mother being a virgin. What captures Luther's attention is Mary's belief that the baby would be the king of a kingdom with no end: “It took a mighty act of faith to believe that this baby would play such a role.” Luther was engrossed by faith and in the annunciation he saw faith in action. Despite being troubled at the thought—“How can these things be, seeing that I know not a man”—and “even though common sense were against it,” Mary believed. 

The dilemma of faith is captured neatly in the annunciation of the Son of God. Faith was Luther’s kryptonite, but faith was also his proton energy pill. Bainton captures Luther’s confliction in a pithy line: “Luther did not believe lightly.” But how could he or Mary? Or ourselves for that matter? After all, the child, who was God, was born of a poor Jewish virgin.

In the annunciation, Luther saw faith come to life as Mary held fast to God’s word that came to her through the angel. In typical fashion, recalling Isaiah 9:6, Luther brings faith home for us: “Unto us a child is born, unto us a son is given.”

Here lies a child. Here lies what is marvellous. Here lies “all our blessedness.” Here lies the child through whom the whole world would be fed. By faith, all that this child is is ours.

“There is such richness and goodness in this Nativity that if we should see and deeply understand, we should dissolve into perpetual joy." This, friends, is the spirit of Christmas.

Read More