The Fall… of Sex
The Fall and The Revolution
I wonder about the church’s current interest in the sexual revolution. What incites this interest, especially since the revolution began over half a century ago?
One simple answer is that the effects of the sexual revolution are being felt more than ever today. A much more complex answer is that society’s institutions have been reconstituted with terms that redress that which they previously upheld. That is, the principal social framing institutions like law, medicine, and education now reflect society’s desire for conceptions of sex that historically have been deemed transgressive.
One feels the force of this social restructuring, which identifies an inversion that is nearing completion: what was sexually transgressive is now a social good.
But even if this is the case, why is the church so interested in the sexual revolution? In short, those who interpret the inversion as moral decline seek answers regarding its genesis. By comprehending the original cause one can more adequately address the effects or at least lament the moment. And so a genealogical inquiry is needed to locate where it all went wrong. This inquiry leads many in the church to the sexual revolution as the cause of the present demise of sex.
However, framing the sexual revolution as the cause of the demise of sex harbours a theological misstep. When we narrate the sexual revolution as the cause of the demise of sex, we unwittingly explain the sexual revolution in ways that mimic the Fall, which, we will see, justifies a Christ-less, yet righteous crusade to save sex. The Fall, like the sexual revolution, is the genesis of the present evil age from which we all need saving. If the Fall names and locates the fall of humanity, then the sexual revolution names and locates the fall of sex. The implication is that society must be saved from the fall… of sex.
Let us be clear, the church is not interested in the sexual revolution, but sex, and in particular, the fall of sex.
The Desire for Paradise
Lamenting the Fall’s impact on the world reveals one’s desire for that which was lost by virtue of the Fall. Similarly, the present interest with the fall of sex points beyond itself. But whereas in Eden what preceded the fall was innocent and not shameful, indeed something to be desired, what precedes the sexual revolution is not sexual innocence and purity, but another era of fallen sex.
We are left with a dilemma: what does one desire if not that which was lost by virtue of the fall of sex? Furthermore, if what precedes the fall of sex is not desirable, what kind of fall was the fall of sex that is attributed to the sexual revolution? Such questions expose the confused nature of the church’s desire of sex.
Could one appeal to the pre-Fall to find firmer ground? That is, can we order a desire for sex to what God desires as found in a traditional reading of the creation account? Of course, and we should, but the train of thought we have followed does not permit such a move. The reason we cannot jump back to the creation narrative is because we are caught up, not in the Fall, but in the fall... of sex. We have already seen that desire has content and it is not for God’s desire. Our desire for sex is in fact the desire to be saved from the fall of sex.
Herein lies the theological misstep. By conflating the sexual revolution with the Fall, what has fallen and is in need of saving is not humanity, but sex. We desire a saviour, but not to save ourselves or the world from sin, but sex. This is the reason for the interest in sexual revolution—we learn that we need a saviour to save sex.
Deathly Silence
For all the hustle and bustle about sex (and gender) at the moment, and for all the boasting of gospel-centredness and Christ-focus that is said to characterise our various churches, books, blog posts, and sermons, there is one curious absence and silence—Jesus.
Where is Jesus the Christ? Where is Jesus’ penetrating voice? Why is the one by whom all things are created and sustained nowhere to be seen or heard? How can it be that Jesus is given so little a part to play in Church dialogue about sex and gender discussions, either amongst people of the Church or with wider society?
Two answers are revealing.
The first reveals the gravity of the theological misstep. Jesus finds himself in the outer or in the wrong game – because he came to save people, not sex. Jesus’ mission has to do with the Fall, not the fall of sex. Sex is caught up in Jesus’s saving work, but only as an aspect of what it means to be human. In short, we don’t hear about Jesus because Scripture does not identify Jesus as a saviour with the mission of undoing the fall of sex.
The second reason Jesus is largely absent from discussions about sex (and gender) is as disturbing as the first. It is true that Jesus is of little use to us for the reason above, but also because we have already found our saviours of sex in the people of Adam and Eve. If Jesus is the wrong kind of saviour, Adam and Eve are not.
Much should trouble us about these saviours, not least the fact that Adam and Eve are dead, literally. They died a long time ago and their bodies were returned to the earth to decompose. This means that the bodies of Adam and Eve, which we conjure up to address the fall of sex, are static images. In other words, Adam and Eve are held up to fallen humanity as the means of salvation even though they cannot hear, speak, touch, taste, or see. Why would we hold up such impotent images as the means of saving sex?
It is worthwhile reflecting on the images of Adam and Eve as they exhibit God’s created perfect, good, innocent, and pure sex. Surely it is becoming clear that their perfection does not bring salvation to fallen sex. What the perfect images do is reveal that sex is fallen. Was this not the point of Jesus’ use of Adam and Eve in the gospel of Matthew: to show the cagey Pharisees that fallen marriage wasn’t always fallen?
The punch line hits where it hurts the Christian the most. It’s a charge of idolatry, ironically, of perverted desire. Gazing on Adam and Eve’s bodies as a means of saving sex cannot be construed in any other way than the worship of created things. Here is the deadly misstep: the salvation of sex is underwritten by the worship of two particular humans. To save sex one must replace the creator for the created beings, which means that Jesus is not only unable to participate in saving sex due to his coming to save people from their sins, but is actively removed and replaced by other created humans who are given the mission to save people from fallen sex. Sex is fallen and instead of looking to God for its salvation, we look to created images to save it.
However mute the images of Adam and Eve are, they are not indifferent to the fall of sex. Their principal function should not be underestimated or underrepresented. As perfect images of man and woman, Adam and Eve have no capacity to save sex. What Adam and Eve are able to do as perfect images is operate as a law that condemns. The law of Adam and Eve are a perfect law and without speaking a word, they judge sex as fallen. They do not bring life, only condemnation. Adam and Eve do not save, but identify the need of a saviour.
We must reflect further on why we continue to return to the sexual revolution. The sexual revolution was a fall of sorts, but it represents the Fall no more or less than the era from which it emerged, and no more or less than the era it spawned. Sex is fallen, but only because the world is fallen. By (re)locating the fall of sex in the Fall, the church finds the theological ground to resist the desire to save sex through its own feeble means, but instead has cause to hear the alive and risen Jesus. Only in Christ, is sex redeemed, which means that our use of Adam and Eve to save sex tends towards being an attempt to justify ourselves, while condemning others.
Jesus’ voice has been sorely missed.
Advent Through Luther’s Eyes 3: Shepherds
In the fourth Part of Luther’s Christmas Book, we take up the shepherds’ task to hear and proclaim God’s message. So passé; menial work for menial workers, one is inclined to think, considering the urgency of the politicised buzz that preoccupies the Christian life in the present. Oh to be bedazzled by God’s word and its proclamation!
It was shocking for Luther to ponder God’s wisdom in choosing the meanest of them all. The shepherds may have been “regarded as trash,” but their vocation set them apart from the self-aggrandised religious and royal folk. God saw in these workers faithfulness: “They stayed in their station and did the work of their calling.” Luther was bedazzled. Not by the angel and its message, but by God’s wisdom to choose people such as these: “Caiaphas, Herod, and the high priests were not deemed worthy.” Indeed, “Who would have thought that men whose job was tending unreasoning animals would be so praised that not a pope or a bishop is worthy to hand them a cup of water?”
The stunning glory of the angel lit up the field, but why was the temple not lit up? “Why did not the angel go to Jerusalem?” After all, it was God who established Jerusalem as the place of worship and religious observance. To be frank, even Bethlehem would have been a safer bet to light up than a field with a couple of shepherds and a few dozen sheep. But then God always had an affinity for the lowly.
Understandably, the appearance of an angel terrified the shepherds, and most probably the sheep. The angel quickly spoke words of comfort: “Fear not: for, behold, I bring you good tidings of great joy, which shall be to all people.” Luther is not slow to critique: such joy is not to be kept to the shepherds or reserved for the elite, righteous, or worthy, “but to you,” Luther proclaims, “Come, see the baby Jesus.”
Here, in the cold soggy field, the great news is revealed to the world through some smelly lowly shepherds. It is of no cosmic significance that a baby has been born, but that a baby who “is Christ the Lord” has been born, requires our attention. Bring no gift, don’t kiss his hand, don’t try to make him smile. Simply go, find him, and receive this baby as your saviour. This baby who is our joy and peace must touch our heart: “if you hear that this Child is yours, that takes root, and a man becomes suddenly so strong that to him death and life are the same.”
The rural light show became even more intense. Now a host of angels appear, singing, praising, and proclaiming the news: “Glory to God in the highest, and on earth peace to men on whom his favour rests.” How can this news not rouse our hearts from slumber, or prick us to move our preoccupied hearts to dwell on that which brings true joy and peace? Luther’s no hypocrite on this front: “I hate myself because when I see him laid in a manger or in the lap of his mother and hear the angels sing, my heart does not leap into flame… we remain so cold when this word is spoken to us, over which all men should dance and leap and burn for joy.” Such is the frigidity of our hearts at this time of year. This is no mere historical fact, “as if someone were merely relating that the sultan has a crown of gold.” Here, in this manger, is God with us, our saviour.
This is the news to be proclaimed. This is the news that was revealed to the shepherds in the field that night. Their faithfulness to the task of watching over their sheep was to be redeployed for the task of proclaiming this news. The Kingdom is at hand without one sword being lifted, or one political party being lobbied. In the field we learn that this baby “rules with the gracious preaching of peace.” It is for our ears to hear, “that this Lord Christ does not build castles, towns, and villages like an emperor, king, or elector of Saxony, or even like me in my own household, but he saves his people from their sins.” How often this joy is lost in our wrangling with the world in an effort to build a world that we desire or that we think God desires.
We are fooled if we think we can worship God rightly without hearing, believing, and proclaiming the message that this baby is our joy, this world’s saviour. God passed over a whole nation to choose a couple of shepherds to believe and proclaim this news: “Our God begins with angels and ends with shepherds.” But I must contest such a statement, Martin. Our God begins with angels, moves on to shepherds, and ends with a baby.
No doubt, we would have forgiven the shepherds if their common senses had revolted against the preposterous thing in the sky that night, but their faith to act on what they heard is commendable and now worthy of the tradition on which we pause to reflect at this time each year. Through weakness and the lowly, God not only reveals his message, but fulfils it.
“God is amazing. The Babe in a manger, not worthy of a cradle or a nappy, and yet he is called a Saviour and Lord.” Let us not sing or preach in vain this Christmas, but take up the outrageous good news delivered to the shepherds that night, which was vindicated three decades later when Jesus would commit himself to God’s desire to save the world through his death and resurrection, rather than taking matters into his own hands to bring about the Kingdom of God in more common sense ways and with self-preservation in mind.
Along with Luther, we look forward to the day when we “see nothing but sheer blackness except for this light, ‘Unto you is born this day… a Saviour.’ The Saviour will help me when all else fails. When the heaven, the stars, and all the creatures glower, I see nothing in earth and heaven but this Child.”
Advent Through Luther’s Eyes 2: Nativity
In chapter 3 of Martin Luther’s Christmas Book, Luther uses the nativity to situate Christ in relation to the world’s powers. His basic premise is that the timing of Christ’s birth was neither irrelevant, nor happenstance. The nativity can only be rightly conceived within the political and social milieu of the time.
Luther notes that Christ’s birth coincided with Emperor Augustus’ decree that all people in the empire should return to their hometown to register for tax purposes. So Jesus was not born in peacetime, however peaceful it was, but into a nation under the yoke of the Roman Empire.
But unlike the relationship of my birth to the affairs of the state at the time of my birth back in 1979, the birth of Christ, Luther argues, is in direct relationship with the political powers of the time. He claims that, “At the very first moment of his life, Christ and his parents had to give evidence of his obedience, not to God, but to the heathen emperor, the enemy of the Jews.” At this point in the story, the cosmic significance of the baby does not shine through, especially since Christ is born during an act of servitude to the emperor by his parents. The birth of Jesus, one might say, occurs while bowing the knee.
The nativity is also situated within a particular social dynamic, which can be seen in the events that occur on Joseph and Mary’s arrival at Bethlehem. Luther reflects: “How unobtrusively and simply do those events take place on earth that are so heralded in heaven!” While the women who carried Rome’s future rulers were pampered in the lap of luxury, “the mother of God, on foot in midwinter trudged her weight across the fields. How unequal it all was!” Luther was appalled at the inhumanity of those who would not create space for a pregnant woman when she arrived at Bethlehem. It was this inhumanity that lead them to a cow shed “to there bring forth the Maker of all creatures.”
Luther observes that the inhumanity of those who filled the inns bespeaks the darkness that had befallen Bethlehem. “Shame on you, wretched Bethlehem!” is a cry of one who is indignant. The darkness is for us to be clearly seen. The “cutthroats lounged like lords in the inn,” and so “did not recognize what God was doing in the stable.” The carousers were full of booze and grub, yet “God left them empty, and this comfort and treasure was hidden from them. Oh, what a dark night it was in Bethlehem that this light should not have been seen.” It was a long and dark walk from Nazareth, and it was a long and dark night in the cowshed.
In the nativity, Luther observes two worlds that have no regard for God’s world. The emperor’s rule hovered like a ghost over Christ’s birth. The mob ruled over Christ’s birth with indifference. Luther takes his reader by the hand to show how Joseph, Mary, and “the Maker of all creatures” ended up firstly in Bethlehem, and then out the back in a cowshed. Much like the unknowing collusion of the mob and the state at Christ’s death, we see here, the unknowing collusion of the state and the mob at Christ’s birth: “Thus shows God that he has no regard for what the world is and has and does. And the world shows that it does not know or consider what God is and has and does."
The emperor and the mob did not realise they were ushering the baby to “the first throne of this king” —the manger. It was not the final seat from which he would rule.
Luther cannot hide his nervous twitch. What is so terrifying about this king on his throne? Don’t be mistaken, Luther is not finding cause to love God because God is a baby in a manger—who doesn’t gush over a baby? On the contrary, Luther’s grasping for this king is grounded in the orthodox claim that lies at the heart of the nativity: “That is why Christ took on our humanity, save for sin, that he should not terrify us but rather that with love and favour he should console and confirm.” Here lies the “Maker of all creatures” as one of us, who came to us, for us.